Butterjoint

Nestled in the vibrant heart of Pittsburgh’s Oakland neighborhood, Butterjoint is a culinary gem that masterfully blends classic American comfort food with a sophisticated twist. This restaurant and bar offers an inviting ambiance that’s both cozy and lively, perfect for anything from casual meals to celebratory nights out.

Butterjoint’s cuisine is a delightful tour of elevated pub fare, with an emphasis on expertly crafted burgers, hearty sandwiches, and sumptuous shareable plates. Their signature Butterjoint Burger features an 8oz beef patty crowned with melted cheddar, a special Butterjoint sauce, crisp lettuce, and tangy sour dill pickles—each bite juicy and rich with balanced smoky flavor. For a more indulgent experience, the Fancy Burger doubles down with two smashed beef patties, gruyere cheese, smoky bacon, and a punchy hatch chile aioli, delivering a bold flavor profile that’s difficult to forget.

Vegetarian diners will appreciate the Fancy Veggie Burger—an artful quinoa, freekeh, and black bean patty paired with pear BBQ and whipped goat cheese, offering layers of texture and a subtle sweetness that dances on the palate. Beyond burgers, the menu impresses with standout dishes like the crispy Fish and Chips, the creamy Steak Tartare, and the tender, flavor-packed Pork Belly Sandwich. Small plates such as Sauerkraut Balls and Just Pierogies are perfect for sharing, bursting with homestyle comfort and local flair.

The dessert selection continues the indulgence, featuring treats like the velvety Chocolate Truffle Cake and the intriguingly tangy Just Vinegar Pie. Whether savoring the rich S’more Cake after dinner or enjoying a refreshing Jamaican Ginger Beer from their thoughtfully curated soda-pop line, guests are in for a treat at every turn.

Butterjoint’s atmosphere is warm and approachable, with many diners noting the welcoming, cozy vibe that makes every visit feel like a special occasion. Outdoor seating pairs perfectly with Pittsburgh’s pleasant evenings, while the attentive, if sometimes slightly uneven, service adds a human touch to the dining experience without detracting from the overall pleasure.

Visitors consistently rave about the quality and consistency of the food. One loyal guest, Finn, praised it as possibly “the best ‘thick’ burger I’ve had in my entire life,” highlighting the superb bun made by the bakery next door and the perfectly charred yet juicy beef. Others laud the impeccable fries—golden, crisp, and never greasy—and commend the kitchen for delivering rich, comforting dishes like French Onion Soup and perfectly seasoned pierogies.

In short, Butterjoint stands out as a must-visit destination for those seeking expertly executed American fare with carefully considered flavors and a touch of culinary creativity. Whether you’re craving a juicy burger, a standout sandwich, or a comforting plate of local favorites, Butterjoint invites you to savor every bite in a welcoming atmosphere that feels unmistakably Pittsburgh.